EXXON MOBIL CORP | 2013 | FY | 3


17. Pension and Other Postretirement Benefits

The benefit obligations and plan assets associated with the Corporation's principal benefit plans are measured on December 31.

   Pension Benefits Other Postretirement
   U.S. Non-U.S. Benefits
   2013 2012 2013 2012 2013 2012
   (percent)
Weighted-average assumptions used to determine           
 benefit obligations at December 31            
 Discount rate 5.00 4.00 4.30 3.80 5.00 4.00
 Long-term rate of compensation increase 5.75 5.75 5.40 5.50 5.75 5.75
              
   (millions of dollars)
Change in benefit obligation            
 Benefit obligation at January 1 19,779 17,035 28,670 29,068 9,058 7,880
 Service cost 801 665 697 648 176 134
 Interest cost 749 820 1,076 1,145 352 380
 Actuarial loss/(gain) (1,520) 2,553 (1,454) 2,335 (1,267) 1,035
 Benefits paid (1) (2) (2,520) (1,294) (1,311) (1,330) (511) (476)
 Foreign exchange rate changes  -  - (284) 651 (43) 13
 Japan restructuring and other divestments  -  - (77) (3,952)  -  -
 Plan amendments, other  15  - 40 105 103 92
Benefit obligation at December 31 17,304 19,779 27,357 28,670 7,868 9,058
Accumulated benefit obligation at December 31 13,989 15,902 23,949 24,345  -  -

(1)       Benefit payments for funded and unfunded plans.

(2)       For 2013 and 2012, other postretirement benefits paid are net of $20 million and $23 million of Medicare subsidy receipts, respectively.

 

For selection of the discount rate for U.S. plans, several sources of information are considered, including interest rate market indicators and the discount rate determined by constructing a portfolio of high-quality, noncallable bonds with cash flows that match estimated outflows for benefit payments. For major non-U.S. plans, the discount rate is determined by using bond portfolios with an average maturity approximating that of the liabilities or spot yield curves, both of which are constructed using high-quality, local-currency-denominated bonds.

The measurement of the accumulated postretirement benefit obligation assumes a health care cost trend rate of 4.5 percent in 2015 and subsequent years. A one-percentage-point increase in the health care cost trend rate would increase service and interest cost by $68 million and the postretirement benefit obligation by $734 million. A one-percentage-point decrease in the health care cost trend rate would decrease service and interest cost by $53 million and the postretirement benefit obligation by $597 million.

   Pension Benefits Other Postretirement
   U.S. Non-U.S. Benefits
   2013 2012 2013 2012 2013 2012
   (millions of dollars)
Change in plan assets            
 Fair value at January 1 12,632 10,656 18,090 17,117 581 538
 Actual return on plan assets 617 1,457 1,604 1,541 64  65
 Foreign exchange rate changes  -  - (270) 462  -  -
 Company contribution 101 1,560 919 1,604 35 38
 Benefits paid (1) (2,171) (1,041) (869) (922) (60) (60)
 Japan restructuring and other divestments  -  - (45) (1,696)  -  -
 Other  11  - (146) (16)  -  -
Fair value at December 31 11,190 12,632 19,283 18,090 620 581

(1)       Benefit payments for funded plans.

The funding levels of all qualified pension plans are in compliance with standards set by applicable law or regulation. As shown in the table below, certain smaller U.S. pension plans and a number of non-U.S. pension plans are not funded because local tax conventions and regulatory practices do not encourage funding of these plans. All defined benefit pension obligations, regardless of the funding status of the underlying plans, are fully supported by the financial strength of the Corporation or the respective sponsoring affiliate.

   Pension Benefits
   U.S. Non-U.S.
   2013 2012 2013 2012
   (millions of dollars)
Assets in excess of/(less than) benefit obligation        
 Balance at December 31        
 Funded plans (3,547) (4,438) (941) (3,247)
 Unfunded plans (2,567) (2,709) (7,133) (7,333)
Total (6,114) (7,147) (8,074) (10,580)

The authoritative guidance for defined benefit pension and other postretirement plans requires an employer to recognize the overfunded or underfunded status of a defined benefit postretirement plan as an asset or liability in its statement of financial position and to recognize changes in that funded status in the year in which the changes occur through other comprehensive income.

   Pension Benefits Other Postretirement
   U.S. Non-U.S. Benefits
   2013 2012 2013 2012 2013 2012
   (millions of dollars)
Assets in excess of/(less than) benefit obligation           
 Balance at December 31 (1) (6,114) (7,147) (8,074) (10,580) (7,248) (8,477)
              
Amounts recorded in the consolidated balance            
 sheet consist of:            
 Other assets 1 1 201 49  -  -
 Current liabilities (275) (279) (358) (352) (359) (356)
 Postretirement benefits reserves (5,840) (6,869) (7,917) (10,277) (6,889) (8,121)
Total recorded (6,114) (7,147) (8,074) (10,580) (7,248) (8,477)
              
Amounts recorded in accumulated other            
 comprehensive income consist of:            
 Net actuarial loss/(gain) 4,780 7,451 7,943 10,904 1,603 3,132
 Prior service cost 60 67 665 758 65 85
Total recorded in accumulated other            
 comprehensive income 4,840 7,518 8,608 11,662 1,668 3,217

The long-term expected rate of return on funded assets shown below is established for each benefit plan by developing a forward-looking, long-term return assumption for each asset class, taking into account factors such as the expected real return for the specific asset class and inflation. A single, long-term rate of return is then calculated as the weighted average of the target asset allocation percentages and the long-term return assumption for each asset class.

                 Other
     Pension Benefits Postretirement
     U.S. Non-U.S. Benefits
     2013 2012 2011 2013 2012 2011 2013 2012 2011
Weighted-average assumptions used to                 
 determine net periodic benefit cost for                  
 years ended December 31(percent)
 Discount rate 4.00 5.00 5.50 3.80 4.00 4.80 4.00 5.00 5.50
 Long-term rate of return on funded assets 7.25 7.25 7.50 6.40 6.60 6.80 7.25 7.25 7.50
 Long-term rate of compensation increase 5.75 5.75 5.25 5.50 5.40 5.20 5.75 5.75 5.25
                      
Components of net periodic benefit cost (millions of dollars)
 Service cost 801 665 546 697 648 574 176 134 121
 Interest cost 749 820 792 1,076 1,145 1,267 352 380 393
 Expected return on plan assets (835) (789) (769) (1,128) (1,109) (1,168) (41) (38) (41)
 Amortization of actuarial loss/(gain) 646 576 485 852 844 647 228 170 162
 Amortization of prior service cost 7 7 9 117 117 103 21 34 35
 Net pension enhancement and                  
  curtailment/settlement cost (1) 723 333 286 22 1,540 34  -  -  -
Net periodic benefit cost 2,091 1,612 1,349 1,636 3,185 1,457 736 680 670
                      
 (1) Non-U.S. net pension enhancement and curtailment/settlement cost for 2012 includes $1,420 million (on a consolidated-company, before-tax basis) of accumulated other comprehensive income for the postretirement benefit reserves adjustment that was recycled into earnings and included in the Japan restructuring gain reported in “Other income”. 
                     
                     
                     
                      
Changes in amounts recorded in accumulated                  
 other comprehensive income:                  
 Net actuarial loss/(gain) (1,302) 1,885 2,218 (1,938) 1,906 4,133 (1,290) 1,008 468
 Amortization of actuarial (loss)/gain (1,369) (909) (771) (874) (2,384) (681) (228) (170) (162)
 Prior service cost/(credit)  -  -  - 30 71 187  -  -  -
 Amortization of prior service (cost)/credit (7) (7) (9) (117) (117) (103) (21) (34) (35)
 Foreign exchange rate changes  -  -  - (155) 271 (90) (10)  3  -
Total recorded in other comprehensive income (2,678) 969 1,438 (3,054) (253) 3,446 (1,549) 807 271
Total recorded in net periodic benefit cost and                  
  other comprehensive income, before tax (587) 2,581 2,787 (1,418) 2,932 4,903 (813) 1,487 941

Costs for defined contribution plans were $392 million, $382 million and $378 million in 2013, 2012 and 2011, respectively.

A summary of the change in accumulated other comprehensive income is shown in the table below:

    Total Pension and
    Other Postretirement Benefits
    2013 2012 2011
   (millions of dollars)
(Charge)/credit to other comprehensive income, before tax       
 U.S. pension  2,678 (969) (1,438)
 Non-U.S. pension  3,054 253 (3,446)
 Other postretirement benefits  1,549 (807) (271)
Total (charge)/credit to other comprehensive income, before tax  7,281 (1,523) (5,155)
(Charge)/credit to income tax (see Note 4)  (2,336) 393 1,495
(Charge)/credit to investment in equity companies  49 (49) (30)
(Charge)/credit to other comprehensive income including noncontrolling      
 interests, after tax  4,994 (1,179) (3,690)
Charge/(credit) to equity of noncontrolling interests  (279) (124) 288
(Charge)/credit to other comprehensive income attributable to ExxonMobil  4,715 (1,303) (3,402)

The Corporation's investment strategy for benefit plan assets reflects a long-term view, a careful assessment of the risks inherent in various asset classes and broad diversification to reduce the risk of the portfolio. The benefit plan assets are primarily invested in passive equity and fixed income index funds to diversify risk while minimizing costs. The equity funds hold ExxonMobil stock only to the extent necessary to replicate the relevant equity index. The fixed income funds are largely invested in high-quality corporate and government debt securities.

Studies are periodically conducted to establish the preferred target asset allocation percentages. The target asset allocation for the U.S. benefit plans is 50 percent equity securities and 50 percent debt securities. The target asset allocation for the non-U.S. plans in aggregate is 49 percent equity securities and 51 percent debt securities. The equity targets for the U.S. and non-U.S. plans include an allocation to private equity partnerships that primarily focus on early-stage venture capital of 5 percent and 3 percent, respectively.

The fair value measurement levels are accounting terms that refer to different methods of valuing assets. The terms do not represent the relative risk or credit quality of an investment.

The 2013 fair value of the benefit plan assets, including the level within the fair value hierarchy, is shown in the tables below:

   U.S. Pension   Non-U.S. Pension  
   Fair Value Measurement   Fair Value Measurement  
   at December 31, 2013, Using:   at December 31, 2013, Using:  
    Quoted          Quoted         
    Prices          Prices         
    in ActiveSignificant       in Active Significant     
   Markets forOther  Significant   Markets for Other  Significant  
    IdenticalObservableUnobservable    Identical ObservableUnobservable  
    Assets Inputs  Inputs     Assets  Inputs  Inputs   
    (Level 1) (Level 2)  (Level 3)  Total  (Level 1)  (Level 2)  (Level 3)  Total
    (millions of dollars)
Asset category:                      
 Equity securities                      
  U.S.  - 2,514(1) -  2,514   -  3,046(1) -  3,046
  Non-U.S.  - 2,622(1) -  2,622  294(2) 5,608(1) -  5,902
 Private equity  -  -  523(3) 523   -   -  502(3)502
 Debt securities                      
  Corporate  - 3,430(4) -  3,430   -  2,125(4) -  2,125
  Government  - 2,056(4) -  2,056  272(5) 7,100(4) -  7,372
  Asset-backed  - 6(4) -  6   -  103(4) -  103
 Real estate funds  -  -   -   -   -   -  136(6)136
 Cash  - 27(7) -  27  57  20(8) -  77
Total at fair value  - 10,655  523  11,178  623  18,002  638  19,263
 Insurance contracts                      
  at contract value         12           20
Total plan assets         11,190           19,283

(1)       For U.S. and non-U.S. equity securities held in the form of fund units that are redeemable at the measurement date, the unit value is treated as a Level 2 input. The fair value of the securities owned by the funds is based on observable quoted prices on active exchanges, which are Level 1 inputs.

(2)       For non-U.S. equity securities held in separate accounts, fair value is based on observable quoted prices on active exchanges.

(3)       For private equity, fair value is generally established by using revenue or earnings multiples or other relevant market data including Initial Public Offerings.

(4)       For corporate, government and asset-backed debt securities, fair value is based on observable inputs of comparable market transactions.

(5)       For corporate and government debt securities that are traded on active exchanges, fair value is based on observable quoted prices.

(6)       For real estate funds, fair value is based on appraised values developed using comparable market transactions.

(7)       For cash balances held in the form of short-term fund units that are redeemable at the measurement date, the fair value is treated as a Level 2 input.

(8)       For cash balances that are subject to withdrawal penalties or other adjustments, the fair value is treated as a Level 2 input.

 

   Other Postretirement
    Fair Value Measurement  
   at December 31, 2013, Using:  
    Quoted        
    Prices        
    in Active Significant     
    Markets for Other Significant  
    Identical Observable  Unobservable  
    Assets Inputs Inputs  
    (Level 1) (Level 2) (Level 3) Total
    (millions of dollars)
Asset category:           
 Equity securities           
  U.S.  -  157(1) -  157
  Non-U.S.  -  149(1) -  149
 Private equity  -   -  9(2)9
 Debt securities           
  Corporate  -  129(3) -  129
  Government  -  168(3) -  168
  Asset-backed  -  4(3) -  4
 Cash  -  4   -  4
Total at fair value  -  611  9  620

The change in the fair value in 2013 of Level 3 assets that use significant unobservable inputs to measure fair value is shown in the table below:

  2013
  Pension  Other
  U.S.  Non-U.S.  Postretirement
             
  Private  Private Real  Private
  Equity  Equity Estate  Equity
  (millions of dollars)
             
Fair value at January 1 489   448 293  7 
Net realized gains/(losses) (1)   11 (13)   - 
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 86   57 10   3 
Net purchases/(sales) (51)   (14) (154)  (1) 
Fair value at December 31 523   502 136  9 
             
             

The 2012 fair value of the benefit plan assets, including the level within the fair value hierarchy, is shown in the tables below:

   U.S. Pension   Non-U.S. Pension  
   Fair Value Measurement   Fair Value Measurement  
   at December 31, 2012, Using:   at December 31, 2012, Using:  
    Quoted          Quoted         
    Prices          Prices         
    in ActiveSignificant       in Active Significant     
   Markets forOther Significant   Markets for Other Significant  
    IdenticalObservableUnobservable    Identical ObservableUnobservable  
    Assets Inputs  Inputs     Assets  Inputs  Inputs   
    (Level 1) (Level 2)  (Level 3)  Total  (Level 1)  (Level 2)  (Level 3)  Total
   (millions of dollars)
Asset category:                      
 Equity securities                      
  U.S.  - 2,600(1) -  2,600   -  2,671(1) -  2,671
  Non-U.S.  - 3,227(1) -  3,227  203(2)5,308(1) -  5,511
 Private equity  -  -  489(3)489   -   -  448(3)448
 Debt securities                      
  Corporate  - 3,872(4) -  3,872   - 2,005(4) -  2,005
  Government  - 2,223(4) -  2,223  271(5)6,643(4) -  6,914
  Asset-backed  - 10(4) -  10   -  100(4) -  100
 Real estate funds  -  -   -   -   -   -  293(6)293
 Cash  -  198(7) -  198  93  35(8) -  128
Total at fair value  - 12,130  489  12,619  567  16,762  741  18,070
 Insurance contracts                     
  at contract value         13           20
Total plan assets         12,632           18,090

(1)       For U.S. and non-U.S. equity securities held in the form of fund units that are redeemable at the measurement date, the unit value is treated as a Level 2 input. The fair value of the securities owned by the funds is based on observable quoted prices on active exchanges, which are Level 1 inputs.

(2)       For non-U.S. equity securities held in separate accounts, fair value is based on observable quoted prices on active exchanges.

(3)       For private equity, fair value is generally established by using revenue or earnings multiples or other relevant market data including Initial Public Offerings.

(4)       For corporate, government and asset-backed debt securities, fair value is based on observable inputs of comparable market transactions.

(5)       For corporate and government debt securities that are traded on active exchanges, fair value is based on observable quoted prices.

(6)       For real estate funds, fair value is based on appraised values developed using comparable market transactions.

(7)       For cash balances held in the form of short-term fund units that are redeemable at the measurement date, the fair value is treated as a Level 2 input.

(8)       For cash balances that are subject to withdrawal penalties or other adjustments, the fair value is treated as a Level 2 input.

 

   Other Postretirement
   Fair Value Measurement  
   at December 31, 2012, Using:  
    Quoted        
    Prices        
    in Active Significant     
    Markets for Other Significant  
    Identical Observable Unobservable  
    Assets Inputs Inputs  
    (Level 1) (Level 2) (Level 3) Total
   (millions of dollars)
Asset category:           
 Equity securities           
  U.S.  -  166(1) -  166
  Non-U.S.  -  160(1) -  160
 Private equity  -   -  7(2)7
 Debt securities           
  Corporate  -  91(3) -  91
  Government  -  136(3) -  136
  Asset-backed  -  14(3) -  14
 Cash  -   7   -  7
Total at fair value  -  574  7  581

(1)       For U.S. and non-U.S. equity securities held in the form of fund units that are redeemable at the measurement date, the unit value is treated as a Level 2 input. The fair value of the securities owned by the funds is based on observable quoted prices on active exchanges, which are Level 1 inputs.

(2)       For private equity, fair value is generally established by using revenue or earnings multiples or other relevant market data including Initial Public Offerings.

(3)       For corporate, government and asset-backed debt securities, fair value is based on observable inputs of comparable market transactions.

The change in the fair value in 2012 of Level 3 assets that use significant unobservable inputs to measure fair value is shown in the table below:

  2012
  Pension  Other
  U.S.  Non-U.S.  Postretirement
  Private   Private Real  Private
  Equity  Equity Estate  Equity
  (millions of dollars)
             
Fair value at January 1 458   393 397  7 
Net realized gains/(losses)  2   2  (14)   - 
Net unrealized gains/(losses) 41   22 (1)   - 
Net purchases/(sales) (12)   31 (89)   - 
Fair value at December 31 489   448 293  7 
             

A summary of pension plans with an accumulated benefit obligation in excess of plan assets is shown in the table below:

  Pension Benefits
  U.S. Non-U.S.
   2013 2012  2013 2012
  (millions of dollars)
For funded pension plans with an accumulated benefit obligation         
 in excess of plan assets:         
 Projected benefit obligation 14,737 17,070  891 9,422
 Accumulated benefit obligation 12,342 14,171  689 8,184
 Fair value of plan assets 11,189 12,631  611 7,048
           
For unfunded pension plans:         
 Projected benefit obligation 2,567 2,709  7,133 7,333
 Accumulated benefit obligation 1,647 1,731  6,070 6,103

       Other
  Pension Benefits Postretirement
  U.S. Non-U.S. Benefits
  (millions of dollars)
Estimated 2014 amortization from accumulated other comprehensive income:       
 Net actuarial loss/(gain) (1) 827 649  118
 Prior service cost (2) 8 122  14

(1)       The Corporation amortizes the net balance of actuarial losses/(gains) as a component of net periodic benefit cost over the average remaining service period of active plan participants.

(2)       The Corporation amortizes prior service cost on a straight-line basis as permitted under authoritative guidance for defined benefit pension and other postretirement benefit plans.

   Pension Benefits Other Postretirement Benefits
         Medicare
   U.S. Non-U.S. Gross Subsidy Receipt
   (millions of dollars)
          
Contributions expected in 2014 1,400 800  -  -
Benefit payments expected in:        
 2014 1,540 1,279 458 23
 2015 1,520 1,293 473 24
 2016 1,501 1,348 485 26
 2017 1,467 1,383 496 27
 2018 1,387 1,423 505 28
 2019 - 2023 6,519 7,480 2,608 162

us-gaap:PensionAndOtherPostretirementBenefitsDisclosureTextBlock